Higher coal cost expected as Mongolia wants to dial up export prices
10 Jan 2023
Mongolia's reported move to modify how its coal exports to China
are priced may mean higher costs for Chinese users, and Chinese industry
experts said that efforts by Mongolia to change the ecosystem of cross-border
coal trade may affect the outlook for Mongolian energy export to China.
Chinese coal traders at the China-Mongolia border said they had heard about the
intention of the Mongolian side to sell coal at ex-border prices instead of
mine-mouth prices starting from February 1, citing an executive of Erdenes
Tavan Tolgoi (ETT) JSC. Tavan Tolgoi is a massive coal mine in Mongolia about
200 kilometers from the Chinese border.
Li Xiang, a representative of Mengtong International Logistics Agency in North
China's Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, told the Global Times on Monday that
the move may reflect ETT's goal of increasing revenue by changing the pricing.
Li, a veteran familiar with the situation of cross-border shipments between
China and Mongolia, said that Chinese coal buyers sending trucks to fetch coal
from ETT will be affected, but "Mongolia will still be shipping coal to
China even if the price rises to some extent."
China has ramped up imports of coal from Russia and Mongolia in recent years.
During the first 11 months of 2022, China imported 26.1 million tons of coal
from Mongolia, accounting for 10 percent of total coal imports, data from steel
industry portal Lange showed.
Some 21.6 million tons were coking coal shipments bound for Chinese steel
mills, and the volume accounted for 37.6 percent of China's coking coal
imports, which stood at 57.4 million tons during the period, Lange data showed.
Experts said the prospective pricing change will slightly dent the appeal of
Mongolian coal but will not affect China's overall coal supply.
"The move, which will result in a price rise, will likely curb Chinese
demand for Mongolian coal, but looking at the supply and demand situation,
China's imports of Mongolian coking coal can still be expected to exceed 20
million tons in 2023," Wang Guoqing, research director at Beijing Lange
Steel Information Research Center, told the Global Times on Monday.
Feng Dongbin, analyst from China-based Fenwei consultancy, said the move will
help Mongolia to be more transparent on its pricing of coal but he is not sure
if the new measure can be implemented in the first quarter due to the interests
involved.
Feng noted that the rise in prices will be offset by recent declines in road
transportation costs.
China and Mongolia have enhanced the joint building of Mongolia's Steppe Road
Program and China's Belt and Road Initiative. Joint efforts are being made to
strengthen the building of the China-Mongolia-Russia Economic Corridor.
On September 9, Mongolia completed the railway section linking the Tavan Tolgoi
coal mine to the Gashuun Sukhait port, opposite to the Ganqimaodu port on the
Chinese side. The 233-km railway could deliver up to 30-50 million tons of coal
to China annually, according to media reports.
Amid a disrupted global supply chain, the two countries' complementary
economies can help each other to overcome current challenges, according to
experts.
China purchased 780,000 tons of coal from Mongolia in October, surging 830
percent year-on-year, per data tracked by Shanxi Securities Co.
Mongolian Ambassador to China Tuvshin Badral told the Global Times in an
interview in October that the road transportation cost from Tavan Tolgoi to
Ganqimaodu port is about $40 per ton.
In the first 11 months of 2022, China's coal imports mainly came from
Indonesia, which accounted for 58.3 percent of the total. Russia accounted for
23.3 percent and Mongolia 10 percent, Lange data showed.