India chases clean energy, but economic goals put coal first •
27 Dec 2022
·
·
Meena Devi cooks on a wood-fired stove outside
her family's home in New Delhi, which has some of the world's worst air
pollution, on Dec. 6. | SAUMYA KHANDELWAL / THE NEW YORK TIMES
·
·
– In the
shadow of a retired coal-fired power plant in India’s capital, Meena Devi tries
to make her family home — four brick walls with a tin roof — a safe place to
breathe.
Although the smokestacks at the plant went dormant years ago
under a court order, there is no shortage of hazards in her air, ranging from
vehicular exhaust to construction dust to ash from crop stubble burning in
adjacent states.
Emissions from the dozen coal-fired power plants still operating
around the New Delhi region feed a toxic smog that hangs over the city each
winter, imperiling people of all backgrounds. Sometimes it is Devi adding to
the smoke with wood fires she burns when her husband, a house painter, has no
work and the family has no cash to refill the cooking gas cylinder.
While the central government gives poor families a small subsidy
for cooking gas as a cleaner alternative to firewood, the main energy subsidies
go to consumers of gasoline and diesel, mainly benefiting the middle class, and
to producers, transporters and processors of coal as well as utilities that
burn coal.
“My
throat burns, and the kids are not able to breathe when I’m lighting the chulha,” Devi said, using the
Hindi term for a wood stove. “What can I do? We’re not the only ones
contributing to pollution.”
Devi is in the crosshairs of a global challenge: how to bring
power to the world’s poor and fight climate change at the same time.
In India as in many other countries, political and economic
considerations have yielded an energy strategy of simultaneously pursuing clean
energy and burning fossil fuels, an approach that ultimately puts security
ahead of climate.
Despite pledges at climate conferences
to lead the world’s transition toward green energy, Prime Minister Narendra
Modi’s government is in full expansion mode on the fossil-fuel front. Cheap,
reliable prices for electricity and gasoline are its priority.